Collegium system is illegal, says government - The Hindu
Collegium system is illegal, says
(2)“It is not guaranteed that the best judges can be appointed only by judges,” Mr.
Rohatgi submitted.
If we concede (1) mentioned above, then all the appointments of
Judges of Supreme Court since 1994 will become "ILLEGAL"& by
extension of this LOGIC / CLAIM all the "JUDICIAL ORDERS" pronounced by these honourable Judges too would become
ILLEGAL?! Then would the AG go ahead
and seek that all those "JUDICIAL
ORDERS" to be SCRAPPED / REVOKED
now?
(2)In all ESTABLISHMENTS, it is always a GROUP of SENIOR OFFICERS who CHOOSE / PROMOTE
juniors as they ONLY will be in the BEST POSITION to decide on their MERIT!
Point (3):One need not RISK applying or ALLOWING a
NJAC is nothing but BACK DOOR attempt 2 gt COMMITTED SC judges?!
Collegium system is illegal, says
government- The Hindu, March 19, 2015
http://www.thehindu.com/news/national/collegium-system-is-illegal-says-government/article7008673.ece#comments
The three
MAIN points of argument by AG Mr Mukul Rohatgi, reproduced in the following are,
all fallacious, rhetorical & arrogantly audacious to say the least!
MAIN points of argument by AG Mr Mukul Rohatgi, reproduced in the following are,
all fallacious, rhetorical & arrogantly audacious to say the least!
(1)"Our argument is that collegium is completely illegal" Attorney-General Mukul
Rohatgi submitted.
Rohatgi submitted.
(2)“It is not guaranteed that the best judges can be appointed only by judges,” Mr.
Rohatgi submitted.
(
3)Mr. Rohatgi asked the Bench to “first allow the law to work,see how it
works&then challenge it if necessary.”
3)Mr. Rohatgi asked the Bench to “first allow the law to work,see how it
works&then challenge it if necessary.”
If we concede (1) mentioned above, then all the appointments of
Judges of Supreme Court since 1994 will become "ILLEGAL"& by
extension of this LOGIC / CLAIM all the "JUDICIAL ORDERS" pronounced by these honourable Judges too would become
ILLEGAL?! Then would the AG go ahead
and seek that all those "JUDICIAL
ORDERS" to be SCRAPPED / REVOKED
now?
(2)In all ESTABLISHMENTS, it is always a GROUP of SENIOR OFFICERS who CHOOSE / PROMOTE
juniors as they ONLY will be in the BEST POSITION to decide on their MERIT!
Point (3):One need not RISK applying or ALLOWING a
"RUN" for a BAD LAW before SCRAPPING it & hence the SC is not
only right in having admitted these PILS against NJAC but also should DEFEAT this attempt at GETTING COMMITTED SUPREME COURT JUDGES through the BACK DOOR in the guise of a HIGHLY FLAWED NJAC and the SC should do so forthwith and without too
much of ado!
only right in having admitted these PILS against NJAC but also should DEFEAT this attempt at GETTING COMMITTED SUPREME COURT JUDGES through the BACK DOOR in the guise of a HIGHLY FLAWED NJAC and the SC should do so forthwith and without too
much of ado!
NJAC is nothing but BACK DOOR attempt 2 gt COMMITTED SC judges?!
Collegium system is illegal, says government - Hindu http://www.thehindu.com/news/national/article7008673.ece
No comments:
Post a Comment